I'm playing Herbie Fully Loaded and it isn't like anybody is going to walk away with an award for this one either but, it is cute enough and it seems to please its' target audience well. Moreover, it is for an audience that for some reason is underserved for movies. Dukes, on the other hand, may serve its' target audience on some level (or may not, depending on who you talk to) but there is loads of other stuff out there for that market. Witness the 65% dropoff it had this Friday over last. Those people are all seeing Wedding Crashers again or Four Brothers or Skeleton Key, etc etc etc. I think what we're seeing in those markets is a saturation point whereby it is almost miraculous if it has any kind of legs at all. Wedding Crashers this year is truly the wonder of the summer. If I had enough of those folks here I would get that movie in a heartbeat. Alas, I have a heavy population of grade school kids and a heavy population of grade school parents and then a really heavy population of seniors. Thus, Herbie is the obvious choice. Dukes, just won't make it, I think.
Actually, I'm probably overanalyzing this (a weakness of mine). The slot I was going to put it in is in the middle of my deadest period from Labor Day to Thanksgiving and it probably won't matter that much anyway. At least I can hold my head up high when I walk down the street though....