Trying to answer all the questions.
There are 2 other one screen theaters within 20 minutes. Within 30 minutes is a huge multiplex which serves alcohol and is very expensive. Within another 40 minutes there are 2 multiplexes 20 and 16 respectively. Of course I think you are drawing a different crowd as those are located in counties of 1.2 million people and 350k people.
11,000 square feet includes the apartments above, but the ceilings are high enough to replace the apartments with a 3,000 square foot theater, the lobby is large at ~ 1,800 and the 2 theaters are about 4,500 sq ft. With 228 and 156 seats, plus another 1,700 in "back stage"/storage.
The apartments are generating $1450 per month, plus there is a church who pays $500 a month for Sunday morning service.
The theater is averaging about 400 tickets per week now. The real test will be this December. They thought Happy Feet 2 would do better than Twilight, so we really haven't seen any good weeks yet.
Thank you all for the good advice.